RFID tags coming to a campus near you

Saturday, 26th May 2007 at 9:01 UTC 2 comments

The BBC was at a tech fair in London this week, and reported on several company’s prototypes for systems which allow RFID tags to be tracked using WIFI.  This scares me immensely.  Even worse, of the suggested uses for this technology, campuses and schools are high on the agenda.

The idea has some emotional pull: how to ensure you really have got every child out of a burning school, for a start.  However, this immediately makes me wonder why the Wifi network, along with all other computer equipment, was not turned off the moment the fire alarm started sounding (electrical faults are a common cause of fires in schools, along with arson).

However I’m mostly worried about 3 things to do with these proposals.  First, many parents are ever more desperate to keep track of their children, to protect them from perceived dangers.  Yes, some of those dangers are real, as the McCann case has proven, though the number of parents leaving children in the same situation has not been revealed, so we can’t tell just how small the percentage of children who go missing in this situation might be.

Many parents won’t even question this new technology: told that it will keep their much loved little ones safe, many will probably be quite welcoming of the technology.  Thus many children will be forced to wear tagging devices without ever hearing of the debates surrounding the acceptability of the system.  It will be a cool toy, or possibly a bit of an annoyance, but not something to worry about.

This leads to my second problem: targeting of Children leads to normalisation.  Whereas adults would normally be wary of new technology, these children may never question such intrusion into their lives.  As they get older, they won’t question why the police keep dropping by their school or college to pick up data CD’s with student movements that they want to corroborate against lists of events that they have their eye on.

At Bradford, we can be absolutely certain that Muslim student’ meetings would be high on the list for monitoring.  Once the information exists, the police would want to get their hands on it; its only natural that once they know the information exists, they will want to go find it.  If a rumour goes around that some radical ideas were raised in the meeting, the police will want to know who was there, so they can build up their profiles, pad out their files and step in to arrest anyone they thing might be in contact with this sort of discussion too often.  Along with their library records, just in case there’s anything worth noting in there.

RFID cannot justify the risks it poses to our personal safety and security, no matter how emotive the news stories about lost children.  Because if anyone has this information, the government will only have to ask for it, wearing an RFID device is simply a convenient method of allowing the government to monitor our movements.  Which reminds me: I need a new Oyster card just so I don’t get too profiled by my current one’s usage.

Advertisements

Entry filed under: Freedom, Human Rights, News, Technology.

Across the world, parties losing touch How to become a media pawn

2 Comments Add your own

  • 1. Neil T.  |  Sunday, 27th May 2007 at 9:10 UTC

    Better start worrying, chances are your University of Bradford card is already RFID enabled, for library access and so on.

    Reply
  • 2. Graham Martin  |  Sunday, 27th May 2007 at 12:33 UTC

    Yes, except UB cards have passive RFID chips in them that can only be read by scanners at short range, i.e. the library entrance gate, or for Oyster, the reader on the barrier. The RFID chips that they are talking about are active: they carry batteries and attempt to keep in contact with pickups continuously. They’re the scary ones.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Trackback this post  |  Subscribe to the comments via RSS Feed


My Twitter Updates

  • Now got a power cut at work. We need spending on smart grids and nationalisation of energy. - 1 week ago

Blog Stats

  • 75,744 visits

Copyright Info