Australia: a hidden hive of racism

Monday, 22nd June 2009 at 7:00 UTC 6 comments

This news story hasn’t been covered as much as the protests in Iran or indeed the financial, parliamentary or any other crises recently, but an uglier side of one of Britain’s favourite friendly countries was on display lately in the form of a spate of attacks on Indian students studying in Sydney and Melbourne.

When the Cronulla Beach riots (often called the Bondi Riots) hit Sydney a few years ago, the world awoke to something ugly. But I think the way people handled it was to simply place it in the “outlier” category, that kind of understanding where we say “ok, this has happened, but its not part of the trends we perceive, so its obvious a totally extraordinary event”. Sadly, this has more to do with people’s mental image of Australia than it does with reality in the major cities.

The United Nations has since condemned the levels of racism in Australia, but the government has essentially refused to acknowledge even the slightest problem. There’s a distinct lack of self-reflection, indeed honesty, going on in Australia about this problem, perhaps in part because any admission of racism would require Australian society to reconsider many of its policies and economic disparities, both in relation to the Indigenous and the Migrant populations.

Perhaps in part this is the result of attempting to build a society from criminals, given many Australians can still trace themselves to convicts transported to get them out of Britain. So in one sense, this is very much Britain’s fault. In another, its the fact that many Australians are actually first or second generation immigrants from Britain who have the same kind of attitude of “everything going to the wall” that is driving the Right-wing parties, (Tories, UKIP, BNP, the lot) forwards towards a desperately difficult future. Indeed, if the BNP got its way, more people would arrive home from Australia than would leave for all of Africa and Asia combined.

But even if the historic culpability is largely that of Britain, it does not let the Australian government off the hook. Kevin Rudd has taken a few monumental steps on the Indigenous front, but has done little if anything on the Migrant front. And so we come to the denial that these attacks on Indian students living in Australia’s 2 biggest cities can have anything to do with racism.

It is worth noting, by the way, that the tone of the reports I’m using as sources for this alters somewhat from the 31st May to the 13th June. But on the earlier date, the BBC carried this statement:

Police have denied any racial motivation, saying the students were in the wrong place at the wrong time.

They have said the crimes were "opportunistic", with Indian students seen as "soft targets".

Indian students tend to travel on their own, late at night – either from study or employment – and carry valuable items such as laptops and phones, Victorian Police deputy commissioner Kieran Walshe said.

What worries me here is that Police are basically saying that race is important because the Indian students are more likely to be stupid. Yes, its the “blame the women for wearing short skirts” argument, in all its fucked up logic. Why should the Indian students change their behaviour? Its the wrong logic!

I know many Australians are very concerned about the issue of racism in their country, and I don’t blame those who know this for wanting to put it out of mind. Its probably hard not to feel some sense of collective guilt for your peer’s actions. But the words of the UN report on racism must be taken to heart, or this kind of activity will continue, and the “unusual” activity we saw at Bondi beach will continue into normalcy. Indeed, my real worry is that many observing this will see it as isolated rather than link it to the reality of Australian society.

Next time you get invited to celebrate the Australian spirit in Walkabout or with a pint of Fosters, just stop and ask yourself what lies behind the branding of these “Australian products”, of how we perceive Australia as a chilled-out, fun-loving white society, and what the reality behind that image might be.


Entry filed under: Australia, Culture, Human Rights, Immigration, Marketing, News, Racism.

Anna: Why I’m making a big deal about Facebook Rape The Revolutionary nature of Jubilee

6 Comments Add your own

  • 1. Lois Cross  |  Monday, 22nd June 2009 at 12:49 UTC

    ‘normalcy’ Please, the word is ‘normality’!

  • 2. Graham Martin  |  Tuesday, 23rd June 2009 at 7:44 UTC

    What’s the difference between Normalcy and Normality? I’m actually confused by this one. And can someone comment on something more interesting than my inability to wield the English language? I was at least hoping for a response from an Aussie, but to no avail.

  • 3. Lois Cross  |  Tuesday, 23rd June 2009 at 13:37 UTC

    Normalcy isn’t a word (or at least, if it is, it’s one only used by politicians in the USA!) Normality is ‘when things are normal,’ a ‘return to normalcy’ was a phrase invented by an American president meaning a return to a time (which, historically, didn’t really exist) when everything was happy and nice and ok.

    OK, I’m probably just being a) pedantic and b) a historian.

    Other than that, I agree Australia has a lot more problems with race relations than is ever covered and that it should be more. And I’d have thought their comments on ‘Indian students’ being, as you say, stupid, could probably apply to most students!

    • 4. Graham Martin  |  Wednesday, 24th June 2009 at 9:02 UTC

      Surely B implies A? 😛 Yes, I’ve probably picked this up from the world of American Politics. Very interesting about the American president; can you remember which?

  • 5. Lois  |  Wednesday, 24th June 2009 at 10:22 UTC

    According to (which does contain ‘normalcy’ so I suppose I shouldn’t have moaned at you anyeay) it was President Harding (Republican), trying to differentiate his presidency from President Wilson (Dem). Since Harding’s presidency fell into financial scandal and then led up the the Great Depression I wouldn’t want to call that ‘normal’!

  • 6. John Torvelle  |  Tuesday, 25th August 2009 at 16:01 UTC

    The hidden racism in Australia is appalling, I have too often seen and experienced it.Racism in Australia is effective because no one will acknowledge it.
    The Cronulla Beach riots are a result of our government fanning the flames of racism as in the Tamper affair.
    Sydney, geogrphically is a simmering cesspitt of people who do not mix because it is hard to travel from one place to the next.
    Whereas Melbourne fairs better because they have been allowed to mix more because of it’s relative flatness and infrastructure.
    Melbourne however is noted as being very unwelcoming to people of Indian descent in 2009.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

Trackback this post  |  Subscribe to the comments via RSS Feed

My Twitter Updates

Blog Stats

  • 77,922 visits

Copyright Info