Feeding The Proud with Humble Soup

Wednesday, 8th July 2009 at 8:00 UTC 8 comments

Food Not Bombs continues to be a very interesting experience in York. Far from feeding lots of homeless people (though Big Issue vendors are always thankful) we seem to be finding ourselves in a very different struggle: proving that there is such a thing as a free lunch, something that isn’t easy in a city where many residents seem to proud not to spend money on lunch.

We’d been set up and serving food for maybe half an hour, and as seems to be becoming the norm, we were struggling to get rid of it. Somehow, free food just doesn’t appeal to most people in York. Interestingly the Muller Rice bus in Parliament Street had experienced queues all morning, as people got their free sample of highly packaged and processed (but supposedly healthy) brand name food.

Our stall was getting rid of its food rather less quickly. Then along came a woman who I feel summed up the situation quite nicely. “I appreciate what your doing” she began, “but I think you should be giving food to those who really need it, like the homeless”. Fair enough, one might think. But she continued “You see, I can afford to pay for my food”. This, joined with the tone of her voice (which might not have been deliberate, I realise), seemed to convey a sense that said “I’m not poor enough to need your free food, and that’s what matters to me”.

Now, I might be extrapolating too much from what little was said, as she moved off rather too quickly for me to ask her the question I wanted to, and its quite possible this is not the most common reason to pass the offer by. But I suspect its common enough to be worth passing comment on. One piece of evidence for this is the number of people who refuse our food whilst heading to the bakery straight opposite, who’s business we seem bizarrely unable to put a dent in (not that we want to).

The thing that one forgets when standing in a street and offering food to “Kings and Beggars and everyone in between” is that the experience can be profound for both Beggars and Kings. To the Beggar, this is a sign that someone cares enough to hand them free food. But to the King, this is a challenge to eat the same food as beggars, and that can be a big challenge, one that involves considerable humility.

Somehow people have come to view buying their own lunch as a status symbol. “Because I can afford to spend money on my food, I am not Poor, and therefore I have Value in Society”. The thing is, its very hard to otherise those with whom you share a meal, and that’s one of the many aims of Food Not Bombs. I shan’t even begin to claim we’ve got it right here in York, but we’re getting there.

If we are successful with Food Not Bombs in York, it won’t be because we’re feeding loads and loads of homeless people, or even Big Issue vendors, and it probably won’t be because we stop people buying food from sandwich shops or stop the waste culture in society. I’m beginning to see the mission as more about challenging the pride which people in this city have about not accepting free food, through which they are able to separate themselves from those they perceive as beneath them. And this could be a much bigger mission.


Entry filed under: Activism, Community, Culture, Food, Politics, Poverty.

Che Guevara is the Opiate of the Masses Dan: It’ll look good on my C.V.

8 Comments Add your own

  • 1. Brain Duck  |  Wednesday, 8th July 2009 at 13:43 UTC

    Interestingly there’s a free cafe in St Mikes this week. Had maybe 10-20 people drinking tea when I dropped in.

  • 2. Lois  |  Wednesday, 8th July 2009 at 14:47 UTC

    Yes there is a cafe in St Mike’s this week! We’ve had lots of people dropping in, probably 50-100 while I was in charge last night. We find that people are very surprised to be given something for nothing too. Sometimes I wonder if it’s because maybe people feel that if they accept something without paying for it, it puts them under an obligation to that person? Sometimes I think they find it hard (especially with the church, but perhaps also with campaigns) to accept that there are no strings attached.

  • 3. John Cooper  |  Wednesday, 8th July 2009 at 16:06 UTC

    Suspect it also depends what food you are serving. Presentation is as important as anything else…. maybe your stall looked to worthy whereas Mr Muller Rice looked more slick and professional?

    I am thinking abstractly but just a thought….

    warm regards


  • 4. Graham Martin  |  Wednesday, 8th July 2009 at 16:47 UTC

    I think this is indeed a consideration. Experience certainly teaches me that people want to eat brands more than they actually want to eat nutrients. Plus I guess people don’t always know what Humous is, so perhaps they treat our sarnies with suspicion.

  • 5. tiggs  |  Wednesday, 8th July 2009 at 17:10 UTC

    Don’t suppose there’s any likelyhood that people feel bad for taking a free lunch when they can afford to pay? I certainly would. It would feel like taking advantage; stealing food from the mouths of the needy.

    just a thought


  • 6. Greg  |  Friday, 10th July 2009 at 14:50 UTC

    People can understand the business model of free Muller Rice. Muller give you a sample, you decide you like it and you may buy more of their products in the future. Within this framework, you try to work to your advantage and get as much of the free sampled stuff as you can.

    However, people can’t see what your business model is, and this worries them. As Lois says, they’ll think that surely, you must be getting some return for doing this, so what is it? Is it that you’ve captured their soul or something?

  • 7. Keith McHenry  |  Saturday, 18th July 2009 at 14:35 UTC

    Wow York has a Food Not Bombs. So cool. Which York are you. York PA, York Canada, York England? I would love to add your contact information to our website.
    Love Keith

  • 8. Graham Martin  |  Saturday, 18th July 2009 at 16:23 UTC

    The UK one. Could you put up foodnotbombsyork@gmail.com.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

Trackback this post  |  Subscribe to the comments via RSS Feed

My Twitter Updates

Blog Stats

  • 77,842 visits

Copyright Info